|
|
Post by ferretpaw on Jan 7, 2011 18:17:39 GMT -5
So, I was reading Fading Echoes when I read that Jayfeather scented a familar scent while he was in the Dark Forest. My thought quickly went to Hollyleaf, but I threw that thought out. I believe she's alive and with Sol.
So I was thinking who else could it be? There weren't any other clans clanmembers there...but then I thought about Ashfur! Sure he didn't really harm the three and Squirrelflight. But he did plot with Hawkfrost to kill Firestar. That alone should've sent him to the Dark Forest.
So, who do you think the scent is? If you can think of another cat, please explain.
|
|
|
|
Post by Admin on Jan 7, 2011 19:06:02 GMT -5
It was Brokenstar. He recognized his scent from when he attacked him and battled against him in the first OOTS book. Hope this clears things up for you.
|
|
|
|
Post by ferretpaw on Jan 7, 2011 20:06:41 GMT -5
This is near the end of Fading Echoes, when he already knows who Brokenstar is. Plus, when he scented the smell, they were Leaving Tigerstar, Hawkfrost, and Brokenstar in the Dark Forest.
|
|
|
|
Post by Mod Blackbolt on Jan 7, 2011 23:26:26 GMT -5
Besides there are rumors (which i believe are true) that hollyleaf is alive there is over whelming evidence of it to much to state atm but if you would like me to specify i will open a thread up
|
|
|
|
Post by ferretpaw on Jan 7, 2011 23:50:46 GMT -5
This is just for some people that believe she's dead. I believe it was Ashfur Jayfeather scented. I believe Hollyleaf is alive and I know the clues.
|
|
|
|
Post by Mod Blackbolt on Jan 8, 2011 8:38:20 GMT -5
This is just for some people that believe she's dead. I believe it was Ashfur Jayfeather scented. I believe Hollyleaf is alive and I know the clues. well ashfur wasn't all bad he was just hurt so he might not be in the dark forest (Erin's have told us to wait to find out) so we cant even be sure he was there at all |
|
woolferstar
Kit
knock knock, whos their, who, who who, NOT YOU!!!
Posts: 43
|
Post by woolferstar on Jan 8, 2011 9:14:58 GMT -5
I think it was Hollyleaf (please don't hurt me) because when Mudclaw died, he went to starclan. And Hollyleaf, wait IF Hollyleaf DID die, she was just blinded by the truth, so chances are, she IS in starclan, IF she died. So, officially, it is Brokenstar.
|
|
|
|
Post by ferretpaw on Jan 8, 2011 23:46:08 GMT -5
...WE already know it's Brokenstar!!! Sorry...but we all already know Brokenstar is in the Dark Forest. This is in Fading Echoes! There was an unknown cat Jayfeather scent while leaving. Mod Blackbolt- Well, he did plot with Hawkfrost to kill Firestar, then he did try or talk about killing Jayfeather, Hollyleaf, and Lionblaze. That's kinda murder, you know. I think he's in the Dark forest. @wolferstar- What truth? She killed a cat! She killed him so he wouldn't reveal the truth, then she reveals it herself...She killed a cat, it wasn't in defense or anything. As for Mudclaw, he was still deputy and did what he thought was right. He was still following the Warrior code, that's why he's in Starclan. |
|
|
|
Post by Mod Blackbolt on Jan 9, 2011 2:32:37 GMT -5
following the warrior code is extremely hard to do so the fact that she tried to follow it i think makes her a starclan cat besides killing a bad cat (as you said about ashfur) doesn't make you bad lion killed russet he wont go to dark forest
p.s. i know it was brokenstar i did not say it was either holly or ash i was just stating why ash might not be there
|
|
|
|
Post by ferretpaw on Jan 9, 2011 17:59:37 GMT -5
Lionblaze accidently killed Russetfur. He was trying to Save his Leader, so of course he'll still go to Starclan. Hollyleaf killed Ashfur, and tried to make Leafpool eat deathberries. I mean really, she could've taken the situation a little better.
|
|
|
|
Post by Frostleaf on Jan 9, 2011 21:36:07 GMT -5
she tried to kill a medicine cat with death berries? that wouldnt work at all. medicine cats deal with plants all the time.
|
|
|
|
Post by Stonewing on Jan 9, 2011 22:01:29 GMT -5
A while back, one of the Erins confirmed that Ashfur was in Starclan.
|
|
|
|
Post by ferretpaw on Jan 10, 2011 20:57:13 GMT -5
Stonewing- I checked, but it isn't there anymore. They must've changed their minds. Some of their info, they do change their mind. Like the Erins comfirmed that Squirrelflight can't have kits, now they're saying that she may not be able to have kits. And I personally, can't see Ashfur in starclan....
|
|
|
|
Post by Stonewing on Jan 13, 2011 17:54:47 GMT -5
Stonewing- I checked, but it isn't there anymore. They must've changed their minds. Some of their info, they do change their mind. True, kind of like with Rowanclaw's gender. xD |
|
|
|
Post by Mod Blackbolt on Jan 13, 2011 19:27:44 GMT -5
Stonewing- I checked, but it isn't there anymore. They must've changed their minds. Some of their info, they do change their mind. True, kind of like with Rowanclaw's gender. xD no that was a mistake |
|
|
|
Post by Mod Blackbolt on Jul 12, 2011 22:22:30 GMT -5
Well to start this debate up i think ashfur is not dead >.> lol i know they found his body but what if it was a decoy  just saying |
|
|
|
Post by Admin on Jul 13, 2011 8:30:08 GMT -5
Well to start this debate up i think ashfur is not dead >.> lol i know they found his body but what if it was a decoy just saying didnt jayfeather see him in starclan? or was that some other cat....? |
|
|
|
Post by Mod Blackbolt on Jul 13, 2011 12:10:09 GMT -5
Well to start this debate up i think ashfur is not dead >.> lol i know they found his body but what if it was a decoy just saying didnt jayfeather see him in starclan? or was that some other cat....? i don't know...... plus there is no truth behind my theory just wanted to start the topic again |
|
|
|
Post by echopaw on Aug 23, 2011 18:35:03 GMT -5
i know ashfur is in star clan but i will not belive that its hollyleaf she IS ALIVE and noone wil tell me shes dead and in the dark forest its me vs my friends on this and i want to be right! XD
and hollyleaf is the best cat! and they found a black cat in the tunnles when bloosomfall and ivypool fell in! *pants* and lastly.... i just want to be right! XD
|
|
|
|
Post by Mod Blackbolt on Aug 23, 2011 18:49:09 GMT -5
i know ashfur is in star clan but i will not belive that its hollyleaf she IS ALIVE and noone wil tell me shes dead and in the dark forest its me vs my friends on this and i want to be right! XD and hollyleaf is the best cat! and they found a black cat in the tunnles when bloosomfall and ivypool fell in! *pants* and lastly.... i just want to be right! XD she has been confirmed to be the forgotten warrior so the 5th book of OOTS will definitely be about her of course it does not mean she is alive (even though i am sure she is). |
|
just saying