Well, in Fading Echoes, Night Whispers, or SOTM (i'm not sure which one) Jayfeather saw Ashfur in Starclan and got mad about it, so it couldn't've been Ashfur.
Another great pic by Snowfeather! My guide to the Skyclan maze in NP game: warriorscatsgame.proboards.com/thread/1187/complete-guide-skyclan-maze Approaching my 2nd (wow!) anniversary of Whovianess! I am working slowly on the classic series. I've done all of Three and part of Four.
Other fandoms: Sherlock Harry Potter Merlin LOTR Percy Jackson