Rosepaw
Skilled Apprentice
*Noms on cookie*
Posts: 179
|
Post by Rosepaw on Jan 28, 2012 6:32:57 GMT -5
OK, so you know how Firestar lost his first life, right? Well, he went to StarClan and Bluestar talked to him and stuff, then Firestar could see a faint outline of himself... so he's dead already, but also NOT dead at the same time... What would you say he was after that? Dead, or alive?
:S
If you've read the manga warrior cats book Tigerstar & Sasha - Into the Woods then you'll probably know this already, but remember when Bluestar was leader, Tigerclaw lured dogss into ThunderClan territory? Well, now that he's Tigerstar and Fireheart is now FireSTAR, near the end, Tigerstar says he has a plan to lure dogs into their territory. Hasn't he already done that? Or was he going to do it again?
:S
In Fire & Ice, Fireheart had just been made into a warrior... but at the beginning of the book, he is called Firepaw... Apprentice? No...
:S
|
|
|
|
Post by Mod Blackbolt on Jan 28, 2012 10:43:24 GMT -5
Book mistakes and the thing about him being dead and alive :S.....
|
|
|
|
Post by Admin on Jan 29, 2012 0:38:38 GMT -5
1st thing- A part of him has died but i'm assuming his main being/consciousness wont leave until (starclan forbid this happens 2 firestar ;P) all 9 of his lives are lost.
2nd thing- Tigerstar became a leader in rising storm, & was a leader for the whole dog plan thing. Firestar didnt become leader until after the dog thing. So I'm thinking blackbolt is right, just an error in the continuity of the storyline XD
3rd thing- typo? I'm guessing they were really used to calling him "paw" afteer the 1st book. I noticed the same thing happens a couple times with heart/star around the time he gets his 9 lives.
|
|
Rosepaw
Skilled Apprentice
*Noms on cookie*
Posts: 179
|
Post by Rosepaw on Jan 29, 2012 12:05:13 GMT -5
Lol yeah  I found another error! :S Smokepaw, who fell off a cliff and dies in Dawn, comes back later in Starlight. He is even listed in the cats at the front (Allegiances) in Twilight and Sunset, even though he is known to be dead. Then in 'The Sight', there is a cat called Smokefoot, but this may be an entirely new cat, or Smokepaw having more than one life... O.O And another!  In 'The Sight', Berrypaw tells Mousepaw that if he didn't clamp his tail over Mousepaw's mouth, he would of told Russetfur that Firestar would of given ShadowClan their territory... but hold on. In Sunset, Berrypaw, then known as Berrykit, lost most of his tail in a fox trap... How can he put his tail over Mousepaw's mouth without all of his tail? |
|
|
|
Post by Admin on Jan 29, 2012 23:04:02 GMT -5
Nice lol. Smokefoot's mysterious second life is probably my favorite of the various warriors screwups. But tbh I don't blame them, it must be confusing with all those different cats.
Idk if you knew about them, but there's also heavystep, who dies and is mysteriously alive again in a later book, and russetfur, who started as a male cat but ends up female o.o
|
|
|
|
Post by Dawnsky on Jan 30, 2012 18:02:28 GMT -5
about fireheart being called firepaw i think it was b/c he didn't think of himself as fireheart yet. it did the same for rusty to firepaw
|
|
I found another error! :S