*Contains Spoilers!* Super Edition Warrior Discussion

[Snowfeather]

Thread for chatting and giving Opinions on the like/Dislike of the storyline of each Edition


Will be spoilers for each book below.

So Far There are 6 

---

Yellowfang's secret cover

Personally this one was my favorite book of the Editions, With Crookedstars promise following really close behind.I loved seeing Yellowfang's past and how it all led to her joining ThunderClan, I diffidently didn't like how towards the end as she was framed for killing the new kits of her mother everyone was so keen to believe it was her in Brokenstar's words when half of the clan was against him anyways, Even more so with the mother.It also kinda amazed me how Brokenstar was able to take all of Raggedstars life's as once when only Scourge could do that, But got beat by an apprentice easy later.

---

 
Tallstar's Revenge cover

Seems I hated Heatherstar almost the hole book during this Edition, Along with palebird in and after the tunnel arguement.Palebird ignored tallkit the rest of the book after he left the den, seeming to totally forget she was there at his apprentice and warrior Ceremonies. Wanted her dead instead of Brindlewing >w>  and actually loved shrewclaw despite how he acted.I think Talltail's leaving in the book was a little late and he found Sparrow&the rest to fast.Heatherstar's renaming of Hoppaw, "Deadpaw" after his injury made me want to reach in the book and throw her into the river.

Lastly I don't get how Tailstar receiving his life's at the end, Shrewclaw had to go and say they were never friends but He still fought for him at the battle he died.If Shrew was sad to see tallstar go and welcomed him back WHILE giving his last words to him, Wouldn't that mean they were friends? Pulling up the "Warriors don't have to like the cats in their clan but still give their life for them in battle" Was really off.

Would Firestar save Tigerstar from being killed before he was a traitor? They were clanmates, Tiger wouldn't care   

Over all I loved this book. (also Kinda thought hopkit was palebirds)

---

Bluestar's Prophecy cover

Was fantastic, Nothing was off to me at all in this book.The Erin's did a great job of making it really sad and amazing at the same time.I like pretty much every cat but Tistleclaw (and Tiger after he was claw) which is kinda rare for such a small group.

~Greatly one I would Re-read

---

Crookedstar's Promise cover


With ease my second favorite in the editions, Again Didn't like leader renaming Crooked because of his disability and hated Rainflower for just flat out everything, Throw her in the river too,

The deepest part.

along with whoever was her friend that let her sleep in her nest inside the warriors den to get away from her kit.Loved Crookeds mate willow during the book and Erins again did a great job of making it sad during the death parts.

---

Firestar's Quest cover

I read this a long long time ago, Almost a year so I don't remember most of it but my respect for Sandstorm grew a lot during this book thus pulling her out  of the river of cats I don't like, I really thought Spotted or Cinder would of been better for fire because sands so loopy.How I remember it it was a great book.

---

Skyclans Destiny cover

I think leafstar is by far one the one of the best leaders of all warrior time, Really high up on my loved cats list.At first i doubted her choice of Sharpclaw as the deputy but later he earned my respect to, the way this book was written during the rat attack was just awesome and the deaths as sad as always.Billystorm was the perfect mate for her and I hope she realized that, Their kits would be adorable.

Since it's been forever reading the book I forgot who I threw in the river but there was totally no off's what so ever in the book

---

So what do you think of The super edition, and what you liked/did not like about them?


And who do you think the next super Edition should be for? I would say maybe Tigerstar or Blackstar need one since they are interesting, or maybe one towards the starting of the clans showing what each leader did starting their position.

[Mod Blackbolt]

I think my favorite of all of the Super Editions had to be Crookedstar's Promise, and least favorite Bluestar's Prophecy (I like all of them immensely but I just did not enjoy Bluestar's Prophecy as much as the others, I even enjoyed Tallstar's Revenge more despite going through the whole book thinking that I had outgrown the series (which kind of ruined it for me, maybe if it had come out a year or two earlier I would have enjoyed it more)

Crookedstar's Promise was amazing and I absolutely loved it. It was for sure a page turner and I finished it perhaps the fastest out of any of the super editions and read it again as soon as I had completed it

1. Crookedstar's Promise
2. Firestar's Quest (Perhaps it is because I read it while I was really into the series, and the excitement clouded my judgement. Crookedstar's Promise wowed me at a point in time where my interest in the series was declining and it still made number 1, so I had a really easy choice for number 1. Number 2 and 3 can easily be switched around.)
3. Skyclan's Destiny
4. Yellowfang's Secret (I liked this book a lot but my experience while reading the other 3 was simply better, still a great book though)
5. Tallstar's Revenge (Despite featuring my 3rd favorite cat (after Firestar and Crookedstar) in the series I just was not fully impressed with this book, again perhaps it is because I am losing interest in the series)
6. Bluestar's Prophecy (Not much to say but it was boring for me )

*Spoiler*


I think how Bramblestar copes after Firestar's death would be a good one (unless the Erins plan to elaborate on that after DOTC however I feel this is perhaps the last series that will be released) we really know little about what happens after his death and it would be exciting to see what Lionblaze and Cinderheart's kits are like (and their names)


*Spoiler*

[Snowfeather]

Meh, The series Doesn't interest me that much either.Used to be like "the thing" now I don't care to much for the new books (like litterly missed about 4 of them without even knowing ;w;)

Who do you think should have a edition, if any?

The Warriors absolutely have to go on, The hunters couldn't deal with the whininess of all those fans.having the idea if the new series came out It'd probably be bland (The first series was full of surprises I loved, But as it got on it got boring, Po3 reviving it a bit then got kinda dull again in Ots)

Probably Lions & cinders/Doves & tigers kits will have their own powers, can't think of anything else that could happen as everything possible pretty much already did.Being the one of the most selling series, It would have to go on.

[Honeystar123]

I've also grown past the Warrior series themselves, but I absolutely love writing fanfiction on them. Anyways, I adored Crookedstar's Promise,I thought it was nicely written, plus the fact that Crookedstar is my favorite RiverClan leader.(But I also want to toss Rainflower into the river.) Probably my favorite Super Edition.

[Mod Blackbolt]

forums.warriorcats.com/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/2241073/m/18410080603

www.catave.com/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/7641093/m/14210811013

forums.warriorcats.com/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/2241073/m/31210724892

Sounds like it will be good, this puts a potential 6th series into question now that a super edition will cover the events after Firestar's death, the 5th series looks as if it will be the last (in my mind at least).

I mean we are going through the story before the clans, Firestar's rise from kittypet to leader and now what happens after he dies.... Does not leave much space for a 6th series if you ask me.

[Snowfeather]

Think I've tossed half of the hole Warriors into the river ^^

---

I'm pretty I've left about half of Warriors books unnoticed when they where announced, including this one (In the wiki page link I actually found a few more to talk about)

A hole year to come out? Hope that brings a few more with it

What do you guys think the storyline will be with the Thunderclan future? Wouldn't be just normal clan life afterwords thats for sure.

-Still hating Bramblestars dep choice-

If leafpool's becoming a Medicine cat again, I wonder if that means Jayfeather will go to kind of being the "Co-medicine cat" or the apprentice he was before (since Leafpool knows more and has more experience)

Also wondering about both Bramblestars and TigerStars (below) lifes given, Who ever gave Tigerstar 9 lifes after that are complete idiots if they weren't able to see how evil he was.

Maybe there be another attack, Or a Omen in Bramblestars storm.

looking forward to it coming out ^.^ looks really good.

---

There was also this one planning to come out, Seems like a great idea, able to learn what turned Tiger evil in the first place, with his time in bloodclan

---

Leafpools wish (pretty clear what this story will tell ;P)

Edit:How much of the total series of warriors have you guys read? Just got one called Untold stories (when i got to the library the hole warriors shelf was filled with books I didn't even recognize ) After I read 4 of the editions (and got into other popular series) I stopped paying mind to WC

I haven't read..
any of the suntrails (dawn of the clans)

The Barely&Raven manga

Most of the Graystripe&Millie

Skyclan Mangas

[Mod Blackbolt]

I have read everything except the Novella's because I cannot be bothered to get them. I think Bramblestar's Storm will be about dealing with the fact that the greatest cat of the past generation (perhaps even the whole clan history) has just passed and left all the burdens of rebuilding to an untested leader and an incompetent deputy. I think it will also deal with how the 3 find purpose in their life after fulfilling the prophecy. (Ie. Lionblaze and Cinderheart's kits)

[Ripplestream]

A quick question: Does anyone know if the river in SkyClan is connected to the river in RiverClan?

[Dawnsky]

It is. That's how they found the gorge, by following the river upstream.

[Snowfeather]

reminds me, Anyone read the untold stories book yet? (with skyclan, Hollyleaf and mistystar)

[Ripplestream]

Do you mean the novellas that are ebook only?

[Snowfeather]

Ebook? I just got it at the library, Have you read it?

[EleoZes]

Burpropionxl Vs Vyvance Cialis Cialis 5 Mg Indications <a href=http://buycialisuss.com>Buy Cialis</a> Keflex Pulvules