|
|
Post by Mod Blackbolt on Jul 7, 2011 19:26:55 GMT -5
Hello everyone since i enjoy doing reviews i have decided to do a follow up on my last one (Sign of the moon). This book Crookedstar's Promise was an amazing page turner with a thrilling and sad plot everything CrookedStar had to go through almost brings a tear to my eye. There was also several juicy revelations in this book as well as drama which the Erin's never fail to satisfy in. Overall i give this book a 5/5 by far the best book in the series (to me) and the only other book that would come close for me is twilight (book 5 of New Prophecy) which i might just like because it was the first warrior book i read (i know out of order but i liked crowfeather on the front  ) anyway i definitely recommend getting this book you will enjoy it i can almost guarantee (unless you don't ;D). Also i should mention that the exclusive manga at the back lightens my heart and conscience after learning what happened to Crookedstar and not being able to help him, i am not one to cry but this story almost made a tear come to my eye. |
|
|
|
Post by Admin on Jul 7, 2011 23:03:06 GMT -5
Hello everyone since i enjoy doing reviews i have decided to do a follow up on my last one (Sign of the moon). This book Crookedstar's Promise was an amazing page turner with a thrilling and sad plot everything CrookedStar had to go through almost brings a tear to my eye. There was also several juicy revelations in this book as well as drama which the Erin's never fail to satisfy in. Overall i give this book a 5/5 by far the best book in the series (to me) and the only other book that would come close for me is twilight (book 5 of New Prophecy) which i might just like because it was the first warrior book i read (i know out of order but i liked crowfeather on the front ) anyway i definitely recommend getting this book you will enjoy it i can almost guarantee (unless you don't ;D). Also i should mention that the exclusive manga at the back lightens my heart and conscience after learning what happened to Crookedstar and not being able to help him, i am not one to cry but this story almost made a tear come to my eye. hopefully it'll lighten my "post-vacation depression" as i read it while travelling home this saturday. sounds like an awesome book!  |
|
|
|
Post by Mod Blackbolt on Jul 8, 2011 10:02:20 GMT -5
Hello everyone since i enjoy doing reviews i have decided to do a follow up on my last one (Sign of the moon). This book Crookedstar's Promise was an amazing page turner with a thrilling and sad plot everything CrookedStar had to go through almost brings a tear to my eye. There was also several juicy revelations in this book as well as drama which the Erin's never fail to satisfy in. Overall i give this book a 5/5 by far the best book in the series (to me) and the only other book that would come close for me is twilight (book 5 of New Prophecy) which i might just like because it was the first warrior book i read (i know out of order but i liked crowfeather on the front ) anyway i definitely recommend getting this book you will enjoy it i can almost guarantee (unless you don't ;D). Also i should mention that the exclusive manga at the back lightens my heart and conscience after learning what happened to Crookedstar and not being able to help him, i am not one to cry but this story almost made a tear come to my eye. hopefully it'll lighten my "post-vacation depression" as i read it while travelling home this saturday. sounds like an awesome book! Well all i can tell you is it is definitely not the worst book you will read this summer (mostly because i don't know if you will enjoy it as much as i did) |
|
|
|
Post by Admin on Jul 9, 2011 23:54:37 GMT -5
great book. engaging & suspenseful. i literally couldnt put it down until i'd finished the entire thing, manga included. at times it was very sad, at other time i felt so angry at the characters oppressing crookedstar for their cruelty. you know its a good book when it inspires emotion  they also did an outstanding job in making it accurately follow the pre-defined events, from bluestars prophecy, and all the events/cats that follow. no gender switching cats or apprentices with multiple lives in this book great job erins! |
|
|
|
Post by Mod Blackbolt on Jul 10, 2011 1:46:25 GMT -5
great book. engaging & suspenseful. i literally couldnt put it down until i'd finished the entire thing, manga included. at times it was very sad, at other time i felt so angry at the characters oppressing crookedstar for their cruelty. you know its a good book when it inspires emotion they also did an outstanding job in making it accurately follow the pre-defined events, from bluestars prophecy, and all the events/cats that follow. no gender switching cats or apprentices with multiple lives in this book great job erins! I agree with your statement 100% ;D |
|
|
|
Post by ivypool on Jul 12, 2011 11:13:25 GMT -5
Mapleshade is EVIL.Pure evil.
Poor Crookedpaw.
|
|
|
|
Post by Mod Blackbolt on Jul 12, 2011 12:01:04 GMT -5
Mapleshade is EVIL.Pure evil. Poor Crookedpaw. yeah but she was driven by revenge (dont hold her to it though) |
|
) anyway i definitely recommend getting this book you will enjoy it i can almost guarantee (unless you don't ;D). Also i should mention that the exclusive manga at the back lightens my heart and conscience after learning what happened to Crookedstar and not being able to help him, i am not one to cry but this story almost made a tear come to my eye.
