Vicky confirms one of ten cats is the Fourth

[Wingflight]

Someone asked on vicky’s Facebook page who the fourth would be, and a lot of other fans answered with they thought/wanted the fourth to be. After all the cats named in the pool above this came up at least once, Vicky answered what is probably the most amazing spoiler since she revealed that firestar would die: “The fourth cat has been named in these comments. And that’s all I’m saying.”

a3.sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-ash4/418366_2846712454048_1446512716_32028306_1588007118_n.jpg

Vicky narrowed it down to 10 cats named in the chat, and I have narrowed it down further.

Hollyleaf has been confirmed to be the forgotten warrior, and the forgotten warrior has been confirmed not to be the fourth, so I excluded her from the poll.

Brackenfur has always been halfway background character and halfway supporting character, but he has played pretty much no role in the series since the New Prophecy, so I think we can exclude him.

Poppyfrost . . . well, besides in the Fourth Apprentice, she has been very much a background character; her character is pretty underdeveloped, beside being in one with berry nose and missing her sister, and being extremely overprotective of her kits, besides the fact that the Erins would never risk incurring so much fan wrath if that did happen.

Though I already firmly believe who the fourth is, I won’t exclude anybody else simply because I don’t like them, so feel free to vote from the remaining seven cats.

[moonrise]

I think it's Ivypool ^^
And I really hope Brackenfur will become leader

[fairytailaddict]

I agree that Brackenfur should become leader. He really is one of the best choices.
And I think the fourth will be the cat you least expect

[Dawnsky]

Firestar. then he goes out with a bang. then he's special at the beginning and the end of the books of that time, and that would be quite cool.

[Mod Blackbolt]

Yeah Firestar all day man. Good way for him to die (gain more respect and become a legend)

[Shadowstalker]

I say Breezepelt. NO, I absolutely hate him. BUT: here are my reasons; Tigerstar approached Lionblaze for his power, correct? It'd make sense that's why he approached Breezepelt. Plus, he IS related to the Three, though only very distantly to Dovewing.

[Mod Blackbolt]

Oh no! Not Breezepelt! >_<

[Shadowstalker]

IKR? It'd make sense though.

[Koa]

I haven't been involved in all of the family tree nonsense nor have I been keeping up with the series lately [lacking money right now] but, while this may be wishful thinking, I'm pulling for Cinderheart.

[Shadowstalker]

Cinderheart would be quite possible, and, believe it or not, she is VERY distantly realated to Firestar through Sandstorm's bloodline. It's pretty distant though . . . but, of course, she might not be since she's already special.

[Mod Blackbolt]

I do not think she has had an apprentice either.

[Shadowstalker]

Who, Cinderheart? She had Ivypool as an apprentice . . .

[Admin]

I think it'll probably be Briarlight, Cinderheart, or Ivypool, just because "important" cats tend to be lower rank in the clan and have been important in the story before. I'd like to see a random outside cat be it, like Brackenfur, but I agree it's very unlikely it'd be him. I think Firestar is quite unlikely as well.

[Shadowstalker]

But how can Braitlight figth in teh DF battle is she's so slow?

[Mod Blackbolt]

Briarlight and Ivypool are impossible no?

[Shadeforest is Lazy]

You forgot Poppyfrost! (Second to last post on the pic)

[Mod Blackbolt]

Hmmm is my memory that bad that i forgot that Cinderheart had an apprentice? Guess after Last Hope i should re-read the books again.

[fairytailaddict]

It is confirmed that (UNFORTUNATELY) Firestar is the fourth *sigh/facepalm* WHT HUNTERS?! WHY?!

[Shadowstalker]

Ha ha. Very funny. APRIL FOOLS!

[Mod Blackbolt]

I would be happy if he was but then again it is April first......